Welcome to SecretSI.com, the Home of Secret Staten Island.
Click Here To Create Your User Account
NEW MEMBERS: some email providers might flag the activation link sent to your account as "spam". Please check your spam/junk folder if you do not see an email in your inbox after creating your account.(or just add info@secretsi.com as a contact)
Butler Manor Destroyed
September 2, 2010
One more tangible piece of Staten Island History has been wiped from existence. The Main House of Butler Manor has been demolished.
The New York City Landmarks Commission denied Landmark Status for the structure, declaring it a non-historically significant building.
The owner / demolisher of the building plans to build 3 McMan--- err, 3 houses on the site.
To see how it originally looked click here... (account required)
